Friday, April 10, 2009

Me being me

Back. After a short break. Rather a hiatus. Did you guys miss me? OK fine, I know now I am stretching it too far.


I've been busy. And of course travelling. I know, I know. You are like.. so what’s new about that?


Well, I was in Singapore for 10 days and that is a refreshing change from all the places that I have been travelling over the past one year. I was attending training sessions for a week. I spent the weekends on either side in Singapore catching up with friends.

The trip was a welcome break from the routine that is my life in Mumbai.

- A barbecue by the beach where we sat by the beach (or the so- called-beach) and gazed at the quiet sea while thulping down bottles of beer and nachos with hot salsa.

- A lunch that ended with us grabbing some snacks at the end of it because conversations consumed 4 hours while we thought it was 1.

- Long walks and longer chats on life universe and everything in between along Boat Quay.


I did work too. Just in case you thought otherwise. I worked hard 6 days a week because during the day I was in the training sessions and in evenings I had to finish my own work and the India office was still working. And of course I went out and stayed out till late. On an average I slept for not more than 5-6 hours per day over the course of my stay. That of course meant that I returned with black circles and not dark circles and everyone at work concluded that I had a great trip. I concur.


What I am not mentioning here is that I have put on a couple of kilos simply because of my unrestrained and sometimes gluttonous consumptions of simple pleasures of life - Hagen Daaz, Ben & Jerry and the likes.


I landed late on Sunday night and got little sleep as I woke up at 7 am Singapore time or 4.30 India time. And since then I haven't got much sleep. A sudden travel plan had materialised while I was in Singapore and all the work that I had planned for the week had to completed in a day in Bombay. So no sleep on Monday night. Tuesday night I was in Delhi. And Wednesday early morning I drove to Karnal.


Karnal is a 120 kms drive from Delhi and around 2-4 hour drive depending on the time of the day. Karnal is named after Karna from Mahabharat. I was dreading the Delhi-Haryana summer heat but surprisingly it rained through the day. And what an awesome drive it turned out to be. The quintessential Yash Raj movie type picturesque drive. Zipping on NH 1 with fields on both sides and moist/ wet air blowing into our faces. Whoa! The fields weren't green as it is summer, they were brown, but still, it is such a satisfying sight to the sore eyes that have been subjected to Mumbai's grime and Singapore's manufactured and well crafted beauty.


I finished work and drove back another 3.5 hours reaching my guest house very late. A late dinner with a colleague which involved of course mandatory cribs about work, state of world affairs, India's win in New Zealand and my passion - politics and policies. Thus ended an eventful day.


I was up at 6 am this morning as I had to catch Shatabdi to Ludhiana. I rushed out at 6.20 and returned to guest house at 6.30 as I had forgotten the ticket at home :). Picked up the ticket and a colleague of mine en route and zipped to the station. Thank God for Delhi roads and infrastructure that we reached the station 35 kms away in 35 minutes flat. It is unimaginable in any other city in India. But there was a jam outside the station. So the last few hundred meters we dumped the car and ran in. We jumped into our compartment and in 2 minutes the train left. Phew! Whoever, says my life is uneventful.


I am writing this from the train. I have written about my train journeys on this sector earlier here. But there is one thing I have to, have to mention. No it is not how clean the train is or that I have internet connectivity thorough out the 4 hour ride. One of my colleagues cancelled out as some other work came up late last night. There was no time to cancel the ticket. When the TTE (train ticket examiner for the uninitiated) came to check our tickets, we showed him our tickets and mentioned that one passenger did not come and we wanted to cancel the ticket and hadn't had time to do so yet and hence want an attestation and we would cancel at the counter later. (This has been the standard operating procedure)


And no, he just pulled out a hand held. And punched in our ticket numbers and Wholla! my ticket was cancelled and the refund credited to my credit card. I first thought that this was some form of practical joke. Then he patiently informed me that the palm was connected wirelessly and he has in fact cancelled the ticket and the money is actually being credited to my card! Am I impressed or what! This is seriously cutting edge technology. I know no one would believe me so I got a shot of the palm and him punching my ticket details..



The Governments over the past few years (last decade or so) have been doing some stellar work. The Sarvashiksha Abhiyaan(universal education) started in 2002, today has ensured that 75% of children between the age of 6 and 14 attend primary schools. Today's Hindustan Times carries article on how in Chattisgarh the enrollment is 97.5%. In a state where 33% of the population is tribal and the only language the parents know is the local dialect, the kids are learning Hindi and English. And these educated youngsters ten years down will soon demand better life and access to amenities that the governments of the day will have to provide.


The next big revolution is required is in education sector. And BJP's promise on spending 6% of India's GDP on education is a welcome step in this regard. Invest today, reap tomorrow! IMHO( In my honest opinion) there are two sectors that provide huge business potential in India in medium and long term (5+ years). Education is one. With over 40% of India's population in less than 25 age bracket till 2025, the opportunity is begging to be noticed. The other one is matrimony and allied services :). Imagine the number of weddings in the next few decades. The recent record was 36,000 in Delhi on one single day last December. I rest my case.

----------------


I write this as I sit in the flight from Delhi to Chennai. I returned late last night from Ludhiana. My train came in at 10.45pm 15 minutes early. No one was prepared for being ahead of time that when people in the compartment realised that train had reached Delhi, a mad scramble began to collect the luggage and rush out. By the time I reached my guest house and crashed it was 12.30 am and I was at the airport at 5.30 to catch this flight. I am seriously sleep-deprived, not having slept for more than 4-5 hrs in the last 5-6 days. Add a bit of jet lag, 7 hr car drives and 8 hour train rides, I am exhausted. But there is a strange contentment on going back to Chennai. :) A friend of mine is getting married over the weekend so have host of functions to attend. I am planning to steal a trip to Mahabalipuram over the weekend. Let’s see.


After Chennai I go back to Bangalore. I am taking off the next week. Home beckons. I have some plans for the next week, but lest that it gets jinxed I am going to keep it to myself. If they materialise, I will put up and update and some photographs :) (Of course, it is related to travel!)

-----


I have been listening a lot to Dilli-6. Rehman has set a benchmark that reminds me of Roja. Yes I know I am mentioning this for the second time in this blog but hey its worth mentioning. Read Aadisht's understanding of Nava-Rasas in Rehman's composition esp. Dilli-6.


But this time I am going to talk about the lyrics. After having been subjected to mostly crappy and at best mediocre Bollywood and Tam lyrics in most of the last decade, the few gems that come out are ever more treasured. Dilli-6 i think is Prasoon Joshi's best so far. I am going to mention just two songs here.


'Arziyaan Saaare' is starts of by stating that everything is about surrendering completely (tere dar pe jhooka hoon, mita hoon, bana hoon) to the all powerful 'Marammad muqaddar ki kardo maula' and all knowing. 'Tumse kya maangoon main tum khood he samajh lo'. Then Prasoon subtly leads the lyrical narration from the seeking Almighty elsewhere (ek khushbu aati thi, mai bhatakta jaata tha) to making us realise that the khusbhu lies within us (mujhme hi woh khusbhu thi jisse tune milwaya). BRILLIANTO!. I particularly like the last part. Sar jhooka ke ek pal me maine kya nahi paaya. Abject humility is a virtue, whether you are a believer or not.


The other one is KalaBandar – the metaphorical beast within us. This one hits out at our facades and pretences, underlying biases and prejudices. From the first line, the song does not mince any words and asks tough questions (he kaala bandar bahar hai ya andar) and clearly calls out that it is not easy to seek an answer to this question especially when everyone is looking everywhere but within themselves. It is difficult to introspect as when we do introspect all we see is our grievances and shortcomings. (aao ham sheesha dekhein, ghayal hissa dekhen,alsi kissa dekhein).


But when we look deep within us, we will realise that the Kaala-bandar are all deep within us. Read this ..

Jaan ke bhi hain anjaan hai hum sab,

paagal hain ya nadaan hain hum sab,

jan se hain hum rang birange

hamaam mein hum sare nange!

Loosely translated as

We know this truth (it is all within us)

yet we feign ignorance

Either we are mad or we are really innocent.

While we may hide behind our differences in front of the truth we stand exposed

( That is a very terrible translation, I apologize profusely. My (in)competence stands exposed.)


And the finale summarises most of our attitudes very succinctly.

' I am happy with the bandar as long as he dont get me, he can stay even longer, it dont bother me!

bandar dont go away and bandar kaala bandar I beg you to stay)


When I fully comprehended the lyrics of this song, word by word, for the first time, I was in a state of nirvana. The intellectual incisiveness just blew me away. I am ecstatic and at the same time humbled by the brilliance.


Folks who haven't heard the songs in Gulaal should definitely listen to it. It also has some really great lyrics. It is better understood when we see it in the context of the movie.


Anyways, looking forward to a relaxed week.


Sunday, March 15, 2009

Freedom of Expression

This is from The Constitution of India:
Article 19(2) permits the state to intrude upon the right to free speech when such intrusion is “reasonable” and is in the interest of any of the following: the sovereignty and integrity of India, the security of the state, friendly relations with foreign states, public order, decency or morality, or in relation to contempt of court, defamation or incitement to an offence.
Who defines what is "reasonable"? Public order, decency or morality? All these are such vague terms which can be interpreted conveniently and contextually.

And this is from the Constitution of USA

Amendment 1 - Freedom of Religion, Press, Expression.

Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.


I am no legal expert, but I think the difference is stark and begging to be noticed. While, the Indian constitution gives state the legitimacy for "reasonable" intrusion, the American constitution is clear and unambiguous in its stance. The state cannot intrude and any intrusion can be challenged under First Amendment. So while in India, the onus would be on the individual to prove the "unreasonableness" of the intrusion, in USA the state has to justify the intrusion.

And that is where the difference in freedom of expression starts! May be, its time to pass an amendment to our constitution!

Thursday, March 05, 2009

Coorg - In rains



Tuesday, March 03, 2009

Blot on my ForeFinger!

It is time to celebrate our democracy. The great Indian jamboree is here. We are complicated and an enigma to any political commentator from the west. We are living examples of plurality and diversity. Every 300 kms the language/ dialect spoken changes. We are possibly a nation of many countries. And yet India works.


I am not going to get into this patting-ourselves-on-our-backs phenomenon. There are enough people who do this on a regular basis. But we also need to recognise the reality - which is that India somewhat works. And it is up to us now to contribute to improving the situation.


It really is time to stand up and be counted. It is election time!! 731 million people are eligible to vote in India this year, compared to 131 million in the Obama 2008 elections, and yet let us be assured that each and every vote counts. It counts not because it will make a difference individually, but it counts because collectively we send out a clear message - that apathy and nonchalance towards the political process has officially come to an end. A message that while we as a country are far from being perfect, we will work to make this a better country, because we care.


We care enough to stand in queue one more day to cast our vote. Because, by choosing to vote, we make our voices heard on the issues that we are willing to espouse and those we want to discard. By choosing to vote, we are taking ownership of our collective future, a future that isn't incumbent upon us by default, but one that we choose to create.


Let us make plans for long queue vs. long weekend this election day. Join me and become an idealist, a hopeless romantic and ‘ We Can’ evangelist instead of the usual cynic. May be, just may be we can make a difference.

Saturday, February 28, 2009

Of coffee and conversations

Last few evenings have been great. Post work i.e. :)


A colleague had come over home one of the evenings and stayed over. We (room mates included) sat and spoke till may be 2 am. Another evening, I was invited for dinner to a friend's place. We ( a bunch of us) stayed till late enjoying conversations over beer and dinner.


Both the nights, I don't remember what we spoke about, as there was nothing specific. The conversations were free flowing moving deftly from economy to religion, oil industry prospects to Tendulkar's innings in Chennai in 1999 to election strategies. We poked fun at each other, cracked some silly jokes, caught up on each others lives, took a couple of snaps and later reluctantly called it a night - courtesy 8 am meetings.


Both the evenings left all of us with a warm fuzzy feeling. As I reflect back, it is not just the conversation but the people who made the difference. Genuinely nice, warm, no hang ups, willing to listen and share and most importantly able to convert just-being-together-time to I-had-a-great-time. I am lucky and privileged to have such friends and acquaintances.


It took me back to college days. I like coffee houses. A lot. In fact, one of the books I am reading currently is 'The Coffee House – A Cultural History’ by Markman Ellis. Quite a good read. A friend of mine from college and I shared this fascination for coffee places. We would always be on the lookout for new coffee places in Madras.


This one time, we went to an old 1940s mansion, in a small by lane. The ceiling had these huge heavy wooden bars running across painted in deep dark brown, the walls painted in rust and earthy brown shades. There was a woody smell to the place, the nostalgic type. We were there for a private movie screening. I don't remember the movie a bit but what I remember is the coffee place in their balcony. I rarely hear of houses these days (let alone see) which have huge balconies.


We sat in the balcony, post the screening sipping our cuppas. Our conversation was lyrical amidst the operatic cacophony of bird -chirps. They were returning home, just as the sun enjoying its little swan song, was painting the sky crimson and brown and orange and finally black. It was beautiful. It was so beautiful that that evening scene is photographically etched in my memory. I can close my eyes anytime and remember all the details.


This other time we visited a coffee place that overlooks the sea. We sat in the open air balcony, sipping our coffees and chatting till way past midnight I think, till they closed down and asked us to leave. In fact while the orders closed much earlier, we cajoled the staff to let us stay while they cleaned up the place. It was a full moon night. The moon was right above the sea and it formed a path of light, as if showing the way to some place. The waves washed up tirelessly thus providing us a rhythmic backdrop. Peace!


I nurture this tiny dream of setting up a coffee house. A place where one could meet new people or catch up with old friends. It would be a place that enables and fosters conversations - from intellectually charged discussions to gossips and friendly banter. A place from where when you walk out, you feel warm and fuzzy. Inshallah!

Tuesday, February 24, 2009

d. We chose to

The Mint Quick Edit today (24th Feb) is titled The Slumdog in all of us. Quite topical I must say.


There are striking parallels between the story of Jamal— the slumdog who became a millionaire—and resurgent India. Both have faced ample adversity and yet strived to break out of the dark circle of poverty.


Well, with a statement like that, who can disagree? The economic liberalisation is bearing fruit and we are striving to break out of poverty. The current economic slowdown in India (read slowdown and not recession) is a minor blip in our story. We are here to stay. Yipee! Applause!


Now that we have established the feel good factor, Mint goes further ahead and makes a candy sweet statement to pander our egos.

Be it our technology companies or the neighbourhood chaiwallas, Indians can be as innovative and street-smart as Jamal.


Now, we know this too, don't we? The example of technology companies is something that no one would debate. (I would like to, but that is for later.)

And here comes the finale.

Ask yourself the question posed at the beginning of the film, though in the national context. The boy (country) wins because: (a) He cheated; (b) He is lucky; (c) He is a genius; (d) It is written.

The answer you pick will reveal a lot about how you view India.


Why not the option of (e) We chose to (f) Because We can (g) We did not mean to. Mint could have guided us on how we should view India by giving us the choice of (e) We chose to. But it lost a golden opportunity and wastefully pandered our already bloated egos.

I have mentioned my discomfort with 'the rightful place for us' in earlier post in 2007

Anyways, the point where I disagree is that we have a rightful place in this world which should be given to us. We do not have any rightful place. The only righful place is the place where we want to be and for that we need to work hard. Really hard.It will not be given to us on a platter.

The part which I fear is the fact that this new found self confidence should not turn in over confidence and arrogance. We have not even achieved the tip of the so called iceberg of development. There is a long long way to go and we need to keep going on. While pride in our achievements is required, smugness is an unwanted guest. It is in our interest to stay humble of our achievements and realistic about the long road ahead.

Let is be clear. It is not written anywhere. It is nice to be romantic, to talk about destiny but it would be only shooting ourselves in our foot. Our well-wishers and enemies are engaging in realpolitik for advancement of their national interest. If we do not get real, I am sure there will be no dearth of people to write-off the India story. To borrow a term from cricket - India flattered only to deceive.


To me Destiny is Plan B. We need a vision to create our own future and concrete ideas and plans to get there. While we work to advance our national interest and influence, the touchstone to our success should always be enduring human values of equality, freedom and integrity.

When someone looks back at Indian achievements and progress in 2025, I hope they arrive at the conclusion that it was (e) We chose to as the right answer. Jai Ho!

Monday, February 23, 2009

East or West, West is the Best!

When I picked up the book 'The History of Western Philosophy' by Bertrand Russell, I was all excited. One, I felt it would help me learn and understand different schools of thought, in philosophy, but more importantly I felt it would help me understand the schools of thought in context of the era in question. And that I felt would give me a more rounded perspective.


I haven't progressed beyond four chapters and I don't know if I would also. The book is well written and it keeps you engrossed. Paragraphs with differing contexts and perspectives on the same theme mesh nicely into one another. However every now and then, you come across a statement that makes you squirm.


The first statement that put me off came right on the second page.

'Philosophy as different from theology began in Greece in 6th century BC'.

I always thought that the Vedas were dated to 1500-2500 BC if not further back in time. Many Upanishads are dated pre 6 century BC. And its not just Vedas and Upanishads but Buddha and Confucius were contemporaries in 6 century BC. So what about their philosophy? And if we were to assume that their philosophies could have been influenced by the prevalent ideas and beliefs then philosophy in Eastern hemisphere can definitely be dated to pre-6 century BC. But how is he so sure of 6 century BC for Greece itself? Anyways according to Mr. Bertrand Russell western philosophy began in 6 century BC. Fine granted. Let us move ahead.


And just when I was settling back, he comes up with this gem.

'Now almost all the hypotheses that has dominated modern philosophy was first thought of by the Greeks; their imaginative inventiveness in abstract matters can hardly be too highly praised. What I have to say about the Greeks will be from this point of view; I shall regard them as giving birth to theories which have had an independent life and growth, and which though at first somewhat infantile, have proved capable of surviving and developing throughout more than two thousand years.


Yes, I know that the title of the book is History of Western Philosophy but the above statement seems dismissive of non- Greek philosophies. Isn't it naive to assume that there was absolutely no knowledge transfer between the Greeks and Mesopotamians and between Mesopotamians and the people of Swat (Suvastu in Rig Veda) of the Indus- Saraswathi Valley civilizations?


So I decided to Google on the fact whether there has been any documented record of Indian influence on Greek philosophy. And by chance, before Googling, I came across Offstumped's post on the same topic today. He quotes from the book - 'The study on Ancient Thought - comparative Studies in Greek and Indian Philosophies' by Thomas McEvilley. To quote from his post -

…The massive transfer of ideas or methods of thinking, first from India to Greece in the pre-Socratic period and again back from Greece to India in the Hellenistic period

Since the ideas in question remain fundamental elements of Greek thought for a thousand years, it is time to acknowledge that one of the major strains of Greek thought was Indian Influenced - that it might even be called the Indianized or Greco-Indian lineage


I am going to be lenient to towards Bertrand Russell, given the fact that he wrote his book in 1945 and was ill-informed in developments in archaeology and the fact that Indus-Saraswathi civilisation was discovered in 1924-31. Not to mention the fact that Sir William Jones downwards had translated many Samskrit treatises. right from 1750's. Anyways, the good news is that Mr. Russel has clarified his undying appreciation for the Greeks and their thinking, so I now know what to expect when I read further.

So while I was expecting the superlative treatment of Greek thought, I did not imagine that he would overlook facts.

... But certain elements had been lacking [ in civilisations of Egypt and Mesopotamia] until Greece supplied them. What they achieved in art and literature is familiar to everybody, but what they did in purely intellectual realm is even more exceptional. They invented mathematics (deductive reasoning) and science and philosophy; they first wrote history as supposed to annals; they speculated freely about the nature of the world and ends of life, without being bound in the fetters of inherited orthodoxy. What occurred was so astonishing, that until recent times, men were content to gape and talk about the Greek mystical genius.


Well, given that the book was written in 1945, it was well established by then that Chinese and Indians had developed art, philosophy, mathematics and science too. Greek civilisation is credited with inventing Mathematics and Science? Really? Isn't that a little far fetched.


By now I have come to believe that Mr. Russell’s undying love for Greece and its ancient wisdom has clouded his judgment and he is no longer a dispassionate narrator. And then he fires his next salvo, by when I decided to close the book.

.. But in Plato, St. Augustine, Descartes, Spinoza and Kant there is an intimate blending of religion and reasoning, of moral aspiration of logical admiration of what is timeless, which comes from Pythagoras, which distinguishes the intellectualised theology of Europe from the more straightforward mysticism of Asia'.

Think Mr. Thomas McEvilley is bang on when he says


In response to the 19th century imperialist view … this investigation has shown that every mystical element in Indian thought can be found in Greek thought too and every rational element in Greek thought in Indian as well.

It is not to say Indian thought and civilisation was more advanced or better than its western counterparts. What ticks me off, is that this book is one of the revered books studied as a primer to Western Philosophy which could influence readers wrongly. The fact that, in the light of new evidence which is quite opposite to the long accepted belief of western supremacy, not much is being done to correct this imperialistic view point is a little worrying. I think we need more sub-continental and east Asian scholars writing about the sub-continent and Eastern Asia ourselves. And till we get to that point Orientalism by Edward Saeed should be a compulsory read for all.

Tuesday, February 17, 2009

Baby Steps

Science tells us what we can know, but what we can know is little, and if we forget how much we cannot know we become insensitive to many things of very great importance. Theology, on the other hand, induces a dogmatic belief that we have knowledge where in fact we have ignorance and by doing so generates a kind of impertinent insolence towards the universe. Uncertainty, in the presence of vivid hopes and fears, is painful, but must be endured if we wish to live without the support of comforting fairy tales. It is not good either to forget the questions that philosophy asks, or to persuade ourselves that we have found indubitable answers to them. To teach how to live without certainty and yet without being paralyzed by hesitation, is perhaps the chief thing that philosophy, in our age can still do for those who study it.

- Lord Bertrand Russell in The History of Western Philosophy

I have always had a great interest in philosophy and I completely resonate with the paragraph quoted above. And the last line.. '... to live without certainty and yet without being paralysed by hesitation'.. isn't this similar to the verse in Bhagavad Gita

"karmanye vadhika raste
ma phaleshu kadachana
ma karma phala hetu bhurba
te sangostav karmani"
You have a right to perform your prescribed duty, but you are not entitled to the fruits of action. Never consider yourself the cause of the results of your activities, and never be attached to not doing your duty.


I had posted earlier here that both faith in God and scepticism can be equally powerful motivators in quest for answers. Philosophy described above takes the path of scepticism - 'living without certainty..’. Somewhere I get this feeling that the above description removes philosophy from faith and religion completely which may not be necessarily true. While philosophy should be free from dogmas, should it also be necessarily free from beliefs?


With my limited knowledge, I currently feel that Advaitha philosophy, beautifully combines the belief in supreme (not necessarily god) and scepticism through 'tat tvam asi - you are that' . These are my nascent thoughts that would evolve in due course. The process is thrilling. And to help me through this journey, I picked up this book -The History of Western Philosophy – Lord Bertrand Russell. I am still reading the preface (quoted above) and it already looks like a great read. It is a big fat book and is going to take me months to peruse through. Looking forward to some stimulating conversations.

Friday, February 13, 2009

It is she, isn't it?

We are prisoner of our thoughts and dreams. For in them we see not who we are but who we want to be. And there lies many a problem. When we are unable to distinguish between us in reality and us in dreams, we end up dejected because of misplaced expectations.


Thanks da! That was so helpful. It is as universal as 'desire is the root cause of all evil'. It does not help one bit.


Well then, tell me what would help you?


I don't know. If I had known that, then I would have to gone to the place where I could find solution, not to you to understand my problem.


I see. So, well, what or who is bothering you?


Hmm.. I think it is the “who” and hence the “what”.



... or “what” and the “who” are mixed here. I don't know. Why don't you tell me.


If you want me to spell it out,, then you will get universal statements. . It is she isn't it?


Yeah!


So what about her?


Well, it seems like a forced conversation every time I talk to her. I mean conversations were simple, free flowing - like the way she writes. Not the simple part but the free flowing part. Its not like I have conversations daily, but then … you know..


So what has changed?


Guess I have. She has. We both have. May be the context has. But I wish she looks at things differently.


Why only she?


hmmm..



... but why not she?


That wasn't my question.


Don't ask me questions. Give me answers.


But I thought you would go to a solution provider for solutions, you are here for issues.


You win. Please deign to be the solution provider and tell me Oh Great one what...


Let go.


Huh? She is not...


I tell you this because I know you and her. Let go. She is and will be a special friend. But then don't define special by the 'what' in the conversations but by how it feels for both of you. Now for the universal motherhood statement - You don't need to change friends as long as you accept that friends change.


Yikes. Eeeks! You can’t get more cornier, can you? I though you were better. Don't give me that now. I used to get these statements in greeting cards on friendship day when I was sweet 16. So spare me.


Well, obviously you never read those cards then.

Saturday, February 07, 2009

Pursuit

Mahaseer is a popular fresh water fish. It is found abundantly in India and many parts of South east Asia. It is a fresh water fish, living mostly in rivers and fresh water lakes. Mahaseer derives its name from Maha-seer meaning big head. Angling/ fishing for Mahaseer is now a recognised sport with camps that have come up in Ganga, Kaveri amongst many other places.


Mahaseer is usually found in plenty around Rishikesh and Haridwar in the gentle waters. However, once a year, during the monsoons, when Ganga swells up from a gentle Mandakini (one that moves slowly) to a torrent with strong downstream currents, these Mahaseers begin their journey upstream supposedly to the place where they were born themselves. They swim up into the small streams that feed the Ganga to find crevices and corners to lay their roe.


It is like a genetic map is hardwired into them that pull them back towards the origin, despite the perils that they face in the raging river that sometimes carries boulders and copious amount of silt and down its path. Not to mention the predators. I have often wondered whether all of us also have this desire to go back to our sources hardwired into us. All of us, in some form and magnitude, overtly or in sub consciousness are faced with the question of - Who am I?


At some point in time, we go back to the place where we were born to trace our origins or may be to the place where we finally could make sense of the world around us or to that place that makes us just happy. Some trace their family roots - going back to ancestral villages and homes in their quest while many a men since the time of legends have pondered about roots of the entire human race. The schools of thought that have emerged are two – one look outside and the other look within.


It always intrigues me that people would take pilgrimage tours visiting shrines in spite of physical and emotional discomfort, while arguing all the time that God lies within each and every one of us. May be it is to reaffirm to ourselves that our individual beliefs are in sync with the society at large. Or may be we seek some inspiration at these shrines. But, what we set out to seek, to discover, lies within us in the first place and we know that, then why the journey?


Pilgrimage as one definition reads 'A long journey or search, especially one of exalted purpose or moral significance.' In my understanding, the exalted purpose is self discovery which tries to find a justifiable answer to ourselves to the question – Who am I? It certainly is a long journey, sometimes even life long. And in this journey some put their faith in God and some in skepticism and surprisingly (or not) both can be equally strong motivators in the pursuit of self discovery.

Monday, January 26, 2009

Republic Day

Happy Republic Day to all Indians, wherever they are in this world.

In its 60th year of the Indian republic, we are still a fledgling. There are corporations even in our own country that have been in existence for longer. We are young, dynamic and vibrant. A nation built on values of peaceful coexistence and mutual benefit.
It is an advantage to all narrow wisdom and narrow morals that their maxims have a plausible air; and, on a cursory view, appear equal to first principles. They are light and portable. They are as current as copper coin; and about as valuable. They serve equally the first capacities and the lowest; and they are, at least, as useful to the worst men as to the best. Of this stamp is the cant of not man, but measures; a sort of charm by which many people get loose from every honourable engagement.
- Edmund Burke
Edmund Burke argues that political maxims are often used as a substitute to truths and the two are often confused with each another. This is then used advance self interest, compromising on values. How true! An observation made over century ago, still holds good. Such little has the political class changed :) And I guess the apathy towards the political class has been institutionalised in our collective memory.

And it is precisely this apathy that we need to change. As JK Rowling puts it best in her stirring Harvard Commencement address (please don't miss the video..)
What is more, those who choose not to empathise may enable real monsters. For without ever committing an act of outright evil ourselves, we collude with it, through our own apathy.
In this 60th year of We need to shred our political apathy and become active citizens in the political process And especially when it comes to voting. we have 3 choices

a. Not Vote - Continue with our Apathy
b. Protest Vote - Section 49-0 (of no consequence but popular)
C. Vote

A. Not Vote
There is this campaign going on..NOT VOTING. I haven't heard of a more ridiculous idea. It is a propaganda which is completely misaligned to larger interests while being fashionable over lunch conversations that people like me who can afford daily basic luxuries can afford to have . It is lethargy and apathy and nothing more. Election day is more of a long weekend vs. a day when we exercise our fundamental right i.e. to vote. To make our voices heard.

The section that talks about not voting consists mainly of people who can afford private water tankers, security guards and own personal vehicles may not need government for major developmental issues. The majority of this country still needs government for roti kapda makaan bijli. So they will still come out in droves and vote, just like the Kashmir polls turnout ( which was a vote for development ). Imagine if the entire middle class votes, demanding better amenities, you think the political class won't listen? And with the constituencies redrawn and more urban votes, our votes can really make a difference.

Of course, the standard FAQs are thrown about, all politicians are corrupt and no one choice is better than the other. But that is because of our apathy so far. We did not vote. and we paid lip service to accountability. If candidates are bad, let us get together, put up a candidate of our choice, fund his election and demand accountability. Like the municipal elections in Bombay recently where local societies put up their candidates who infact won the election.

B. Protest Vote - Section 49-O.

Section 49-O has been labeled as a 'protest vote'. This is completely false. I would guide you to Mr. Uday Singh's article which does a brilliant job of dispelling the myth.

Briefly, the system in India is designed towards number of votes for a candidate vs. number against or absenteeism. For. e.g. in a constituency of 1000 voters, even if 999 decide to opt for sectio 49-O and one person votes for candidate A then candidate A wins. We do not have a minimum percentage any such criteria. So by exercising 49-O we are infact not utilising our vote properly. And not just that. As it is our voting percentage is 60% and today the winner gets at maximum 15-20% of the total votes of the constituency he is representing. If you do not vote, he or she is likely to get at maximum 5-10% of votes and still represent us. And if a candidate with 5-10% of votes wins then he is more likely than not have predilection towards a community or caste as he would have got their backing.

C. Let us VOTE!
So let us all understand the importance of our vote and cast our vote in this coming election. Lets take our voting percentage upto 70%. And once we have exercised our vote and elected our leaders, let us be active citizens and demand accountability. Let us use RTI act, let us monitor funds usage, track and measure progress in our constituency. Let us get involved and seek answers.

I would like to leave you with this thought. Its time to stand up and be counted.
The Republic was not established by cowards;
and cowards will not preserve it …
This will remain the land of the free
only so long as it is the home of the brave. ~Elmer Davis
Linked from Pragmatic

Saturday, January 24, 2009

India's Titanic???

On Slumdog Millionaire ‘phenomenon’, I read an article few days ago paper that how we react to SM will define how mature we are as a society. Yeah right! And especially when I read reviews of SM which say 'A peep into soul of India' I cringe. And this is what Nirpal Dhaliwal from Guardian says


“so many Indians will be upset about a westerner having a better understanding of their country than they do.

The bitter truth is, Slumdog Millionaire could only have been made by westerners.

As an outsider, he saw the truth that middle-class Indians are too often inured to: that countless people exist in conditions close to hell yet maintain a breath-taking exuberance, dignity and decency. These people embody the tremendous spirit and strength of India and its civilisation. They deserve the attention of its film-makers. I have no doubt that Slumdog Millionaire will encourage many more honest films to be produced in India. But they should be ashamed that it took a white man to show India how to do it.”


Am I allowed to pass judgment on this loser? Look at this. SM could have been made by Westerners. Or ‘ they should be ashamed that it took a white man to show India how to do it’. Mr. Dhaliwal, stop sucking up to your bosses at the Guardian. I mean really! Of course, white men know India better. And it took you SM to figure that out. Rigggghttt!


I saw the movie yesterday and it is nothing but a masala movie. It is slickly made with great editing but no way it is the real India. It is as real India as Paris Hilton or Britney Spears is real America. Let me make it clear here that I don't think I alone represent the soul of this country and neither do my experiences. But I represent one aspect of this country, just like people in slums or I-bankers of Nariman point. Also I am aware of the fact that close to 70% of this country live below the poverty line or just above it. But what enrages me is calling ‘poverty and depravity and the spirit of these Slumdogs the soul of this country time and again and again and again while conveniently glossing over the other aspects. If Mr. Dhaliwal says that Indian movies gloss over the ‘underbelly’ then be assured that movies about India in the west pander the ‘underbelly’ glossing over the rest. How sad!


Now, I am sure that there are people who would blame me for being jingoistic simply because the ‘poor India’ is portrayed here. I do not feel any shame or embarrassment, anger or resentment or any such thing. It’s a movie that could have been set in ghettos of Brazil or shanties of Mexico City or in any urban squalor. But what enrages me is the epithets this movie is getting in spite of the ‘glossing’ over.


And here is an example. Interview Mr. Naseeruddin Shan on A Wednesday from HT.

Why wasn’t the film taken to festivals and pitched for international awards?
Neeraj:
Ours is not a festival film, it’s only for private consumption. (Smiles)
Naseer: Our producers are lazy chaps. They didn’t want to move their butts from their offices to take the film to international festivals. (Smiles) Jokes apart,
A Wednesday should have gone to the festivals but it didn’t because the goras have their own preconceived notions. (Making a face) According to the guys at the Toronto Film Festival, our movie didn’t conform to their ideas about India.

Well, even if Mr. Naseeruddin Shah is exaggerating the ‘Gora’ effect, what does Mr. Dhaliwal, what do you have to say about this?


But you know what, there are so many positives from the movie. If an Indian had made the movie, it would at best be in one category – best foreign movie. But now its in 10 categories. Look at the publicity the movie is garnering. AR Rehman is good in the movie, but it isn’t his best by any count. Roja, Dil Se, Kaanathil Mutham Vittal, Dil Se, Bombay and of course Thiruda Thiruda are one or even two notches higher. But he is getting all the global attention which he rightly deserves and the western audiences will now listen to his other compositions. The other thing that I am happy about is that this is a great business opportunity for India with 10 Oscar nominations. As ARR, put it very nicely, ‘It is a great energy booster for the creative folks in India’. I expect more India based movies, more Indian actors, technicians and musicians getting more opportunities on a larger stage. So let us just enjoy this moment, revel in our awards and move on, glossing over these discussions :P


Edited to Add: Khalid Mohammed who writes in HT has always been one of my favourite movie writers/ critics. His reviews of most Hindi movies were spot on. But after awarding 5 stars to SM, I have just one question for him. If, SM were made in India, by one of the Indian directors, then would you Mr. Khalid Mohammed view it through the same forgiving eyes?

‘Inevitably, that classic forgiveness factor is involved in overlooking several implausible points like the reunion with blinded child beggar. Then there are omissions .. and allowance of a clipped British accent … more co incidences than you could catch in a TV soap.’ Hah! So will you now allow the ‘forgiveness factor’ in all your reviews of Hindi movies?

Edited to add again: Waiting for the media to call SM India’s Titanic soon. Given our history of India’s 9/11 etc.